Friday, December 16, 2011

Maggie's Peanut Butter Pie

I have been wanting to post this recipe for several weeks now. There is a lady in our town who owns a little restaurant called "Maggie's Buns" and has a catering business. All I have had she has made has been DELICIOUS! I love to go to local weddings when she caters them! She posted this recipe in a little holiday section of the newspaper and I consider it a holiday gift. This pie is like the type of pie you buy in a fancy restaurant and pay like $8 for a tiny sliver and then realize it is worth every cent!

Okay, I cut this slice not knowing how rich it is.  Wyatt and I had to share this slice. Of course--a couple hours later I wanted to have it again!

Maggie says she suggests this recipe for when last minute holiday guests arrive. Guests? I wanted to eat the whole thing myself.  Here is the recipe...

Maggie's Peanut Butter pie

Pre-made Graham Cracker crust

Pie Filling:
8 oz. cream cheese
1 cup peanut Butter
1/2 cup sugar
2 T. Butter
A good swig of whiskey, bourbon or vanilla
(Cool Whip)

Pot de Creme:
1 cup chocolate chips
1/2 cup half and half

topping: Reese's Peanut Butter cups or peanuts

Beat pie filling ingredients until creamy. Add 2 cups Cool Whip and beat until incorporated.
 Pour pie ingredients into pre-made graham cracker crust and set aside.

Melt chocolate chips and half and half in microwave for 2 minutes. Beat with a fork until mixture is very shiny. Pour over the top of your peanut butter mixture.

To add a little flair to your pie you can chop peanuts and/or peanut butter cups and sprinkle over the top. Keep refrigerated until serving.

Thats it! So easy and so delicious. Posting this recipe is making me crave it so bad--I want to make it right now! Of course, I have to limit myself because it is so good that if I make it often I would have to have one of the kids roll me over to the computer so I can do blog posts!



cathy@home said...

That pie looks delicious I wanted to rush out and make it but what is "cool whip"?

Unknown said...

I don't like peanut butter , but everyone else in my family does . They all think I'm crazy. I'm just glad there is one fatting thing on this planet that I don't like . lol

Myric said...

My husband is crazy about peanut butter recipes!! This looks really awesome!
The story about your daughter called you about my dryer sheets project was so sweet!!! I am SOO happy to learned you both liked my little project.
I want to see yours if you are planning to make one :)


Phyllis @Around the House said...

your pie looks yummy...gotta try it soon

Karen said...

Wow that sounds rich and delicious! I probably would put myself in a stupor from gorging on it.

Brandi said...

Your pie looks so delicious! You had me at peanut butter! LOL!!

Anonymous said...

I have had this pie before and it is so yummy!!!

Rosemary@villabarnes said...

OMGoodness. This looks delish! Thanks for the recipe.

Anonymous said...

This looks amazing! It sounds so yummy! Thanks for sharing the recipe! Merry Christmas!

Passionate for White said...

Looks yummy!!!

koralee said...

Oh my husband and daughters would sooo enjoy this...I am thinking I must make this over the holidays...thank you so much for sharing the JOY....xoxoxo